Increasingly in today’s business climate, B2B companies are being evaluated—formally and informally—on what they stand for. Regardless of intent, organizations are being perceived through the optics of broader societal values, and how they manage that perception can mean the difference between lasting trust and lost partnerships.

​

Recent data reflects a growing convergence between business and public values. Nearly 7 in 10 Americans now prefer to buy from brands that reflect their personal beliefs and almost a quarter have changed providers due to value misalignment, reflecting how reputational risks tied to social issues are now deeply embedded in capital decision-making. It matters now, more than ever, what a company stands for. While this has been known for a decade or more, it has only been recently that this trend has started affecting the B2B transactions.

​

The Business Risks of Cultural Polarization
In the B2B world, 89% of executives now consider social and cultural polarization a business risk, and nearly 60% report that navigating today’s operating environment is more complex than it was, even compared to just a few years ago. More than two-thirds of executives also say brand purpose is now a critical factor in competitive positioning. It’s not just the value of a service or product a company offers that matters, it’s the values the company champions.

​

In some sectors, agencies and partners are reassessing vendor relationships based not only on performance metrics, but also on perceived alignment with institutional values. This landscape requires more than reactive positioning. It requires clarity—and above all, consistency. This complexity has only grown in the wake of shifting regulatory and cultural expectations.

​

Unfortunately, many businesses are responding to this pressure by trying to chameleon into whatever politicized climate they’re trying to do business in. This has led to many becoming more reactive, and not more resilient. In 2023,  Deloitte’s 2023 Global Procurement Officer Survey named ESG the No. 2 Highest Priority for Procurement Executives. Yet, following the changeup in political climate after the 2024 US Election, CPOs reported that ESG was a bottom priority in their procurement strategy, according to EY’s 2025 CPO Survey. This isn’t about political orientation. It’s about whether an organization’s stated principles remain stable when external conditions change.

 

The Critical Element—Trust
Companies refresh mission statements, revise value propositions, and recalibrate messaging in response to public pressure. But stakeholders are increasingly discerning. Trust is eroding. Only 36% of people believe companies consistently act on their values. In B2B, where relationships are built on long-term reliability, that erosion carries real consequences.

 

These consequences show up in tangible ways. Partnerships stall. Contracts are lost. Reputations are scrutinized more closely than ever. When you can’t trust your business partners to continue standing for what they claim are “core values” and a “driving purpose,” then how deep can trust really go?

 

At the same time, informal clustering is beginning to emerge across industries. Businesses are forming networks of like-minded partners based on shared approaches to values, ethics, or risk. In this environment, reputational association is a growing concern. A single vendor’s controversy can quickly spill over to affect every company in its supply chain. Business partners want to know what to expect from the groups they work with. One McKinsey report noted that over 70% of supply chain leaders now consider reputational risk from third-party behavior when making partnership decisions.

 

Actions Based on Priciples, Not Popularity
The companies with a clearly defined and consistent set of guiding principles are best positioned to respond with credibility and are more stable partners in the long run. That’s where the distinction between clarity and consistency becomes essential.

​

It’s not enough to have polished messaging. Stakeholders expect actions to match values over time. Companies that approach value expression as a marketing exercise often find themselves alienating both customers and partners. Well-publicized missteps—especially in values-driven campaigns—underscore how quickly support erodes when an organization appears to pivot under pressure. These cases highlight not failure of intention, but failure of alignment.

​

While these examples are most often drawn from consumer-facing brands, the lessons are just as relevant in B2B. Trust in this space is developed over years and spans entire organizations. It depends on a perception of stability and principle, not opportunism.

​

Authenticity and Strategic Resilience
So what’s the alternative to reactive positioning? It’s not silence. Nor is it neutrality for its own sake. It’s authenticity: the consistent expression of who a company is, what it values, and how those values shape decisions at every level. Say what you mean, and stand for what you believe in. Neither buzzwords nor rebranding will be able to instill what consistent authenticity does.

​

Authenticity is more than a brand virtue—it’s a business asset. Organizations that are seen as authentic gain strategic resilience. They build reputational capital that can withstand controversy. IBM has long integrated ESG commitments into its core strategy—from decarbonization efforts to inclusive hiring practices. While individual partners may interpret or prioritize these issues differently, few question IBM’s consistency in upholding its values over time, which is precisely what reinforces trust within its partner ecosystem. Similarly, brands that have embedded social mission into their identity over time tend to weather external challenges more effectively—not because they avoid scrutiny, but because they are consistent and transparent.

​

In B2B, this consistency translates to clearer decision-making and stronger partnerships. Businesses want to work with partners they understand. A clear set of principles helps set expectations, manage risks, and strengthen trust. Dentsu’s 2024 B2B Superpowers Index found that shared values were a top driver of emotional loyalty and long-term account growth. When values are embedded into operations—not just marketing or public statements—they become part of how a company hires, sources, innovates, and collaborates. This alignment increases internal cohesion and builds external confidence.

 

Prioritization and Transparency: Foundations of Authenticity
The path to authenticity begins with focus. No company can take a stance on every issue. But every company can define and live by a core set of values. Prioritize one to three principles that align with your mission and stakeholder expectations. Make them visible not only in messaging, but in strategy and execution. Be clear and transparent—internally and externally—about how those values guide decisions. When stakeholders see that alignment hold over time, trust follows.

 

Leaders must ensure that values aren’t isolated in a brand handbook—they must be reinforced at every touchpoint of the business. Internal alignment becomes just as important as external messaging, because employees are often the first to spot—and call out—discrepancies between what’s said and what’s done. Not only does it demonstrate externally a commitment to credibility and reliability, but it also establishes those commitments as a truth directing the business, built by those who work there.

​

It’s also important to document and revisit value-driven decisions. Whether a company chooses to enter or exit a market, decline a partnership, or shift investment due to values, explaining the reasoning internally and externally can reinforce clarity and earn respect. Stakeholders understand that difficult choices have to be made. Knowing that a company, while striving for profits, does mean it when they say they believe in their guiding principles, builds respect and trust in not only the brand but their word.

​

Stability Through Consistent Values
Ultimately, authenticity allows a company to operate from a position of strength. When the external environment shifts—and it will—leaders who’ve grounded their organizations in clearly articulated, consistently applied values won’t need to scramble. They’ll already know what to do. And just as importantly, so will their stakeholders.

​

In a fast-changing market, values provide a stable compass. Authenticity is not a communications tactic. It’s a strategic foundation. One that Rob Roy strives to help all its clients establish and maintain. For B2B organizations seeking trust, loyalty, and resilience, it’s one of the few competitive advantages that cannot be replicated. While external pressures will continue to evolve, the companies that navigate them most effectively will be those grounded in a clear, consistent identity. The risk is not in having values. The risk is in having values that shift with every headline.